Monday, September 19, 2011

How J.K. Rowling and Harry Potter influence feminism in media today - Draft #2

Pen names have always been a common trend in the writing world. This is due to the fact that authors wanted their works to be judged by their writing not by who they were or where they were from or what nationality they were. Authors have abbreviated their names since the earliest of records for both ease of memorization and neural views by the public. This includes C.S. Lewis, Homer, and one of today most well known author, J.K. Rowling. One does not even have to get to her last name before an image of Harry Potter appears. But the author is not the sole decision maker in pen names. Before the world knew of Harry Potter and J.K Rowling, Joanne Rowling was simply trying to make a living by writing stories. In her case, it was the publisher who insisted on the use of a pen name in order to appeal to a larger audience. A larger audience in this case meaning both boys and girls because, according to her publisher, boys are less likely to read novels by female authors. Whether or not this strategy worked better than not having the pen name, no one will ever know however it does give insight into our society. As adults do we encourage this behavior of discriminating authors based on their gender or is this an idea formed from within? This male perspective on everything, or the male gaze, then becomes inherent. Now, does the same thing apply but to girls wanting to read Harry Potte


Another thing to note is the absence of an about the author column on the back page of all Harry Potter book covers (see Image 1). Whether this was intentional for the sake of eliminating discrimination or in order to have a full picture of the story, I cannot quite be sure. As a fan of Harry Potter, I love being able to see J.K Rowling’s depiction of the story. It is a look into her vision of the wizarding world. It also brings up the question of whether the publisher did this on purpose or not. Despite the popular phrase, almost everyone judges a book by its cover. In advertising, the book jacket is a vital part in attracting readers and gaining a fan base. As a book intended for children, the images displayed on the book jacket are cartoon-like and are gender neutral, displaying no ‘male gaze’ point of view.r? Women and girls are often portrayed as the fragile and pure members of society. When authors such as Joanne Rowling publish under a pen name J.K Rowling, we as a society are settling. It is often hard pressed to get into the writing business, especially as a female, but settling for a pen name in order to ‘get in’ can be considered unproductive in strict feminist views. However, J.K Rowling did a great thing by gaining a seat for “women at the proverbial table,” inspiring young authors that anyone with a goal in mind can achieve that which they set out to do (Zeisler, 2008, p 21).

Harry Potter as a whole is a gateway to new realms of feminism and outlooks of the roles of women. When discussing the topic of feminism, my girlfriends and I concluded that we as females want to be recognized as strong and able yet men should continue to be chivalrous towards us. Rowling effectively used female supporting characters to carry the story and display this modern view on feminism. The most obvious of female characters is Hermione Granger. From the start she is a book worm, a nerd, a geek, an outlier. As a reader you are put into the situation of wanting to root for the outcasts and are given a sense of the humiliation they go through. Throughout the course of all seven books, Rowling builds Hermione in all aspects. Her smarts are appreciated and life saving in many situations while she also matures in her looks and becomes attractive while maintaining her geeky ways. The second major female character in Harry Potter is Ginny Weasley. Growing up as the only girl born in the family line and having five brothers, Ginny was always on her own, fighting for her place in a house full of boys. Although her brothers never let her play quidditch with them, she would sneak outside to practice, defying all rules set by her mother and traditional role. Despite the many strong modern female characters, Rowling also introduces the reader to more traditional female roles. As the caregiver and motherly figure in the books, Madam Pomfery is the typical school nurse who is both kind yet strict. She is essential to the Harry Potter books as she keeps Harry alive multiple times throughout his schooling.


Harry Potter Book Cover Art. N.d. JPEG file.

Zeisler, Andi. Feminism and Pop Culture. Berkeley: Seal Press, 2008. Print.

5 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Kath's blog talks about specifically female writer JK Rowling and her book Harry Potter as a whole in representing women figures in pop culture. The blog quite well attracts readers by using visual image as well as some story plots from Harry Potter in the later article. But personally, I find it a little incohesive in the main stance. In the first paragraph, its focuses on the difficulty women authors face in writing industry and they are forced to adopt a male pen name for success, then in the third paragraph it shifts to how some of JK Rowling's feminine strive for female independence. Thought it can be modified by saying that" although JK Rowling has no choice but to adopt a man's pen name for success, she herself looks forward a increase in female rights and independence which can be seen by some of her female characters". The language used is fairly formal, which is appropriate for informative writing. Besides, think can add pictures of Hermione and Ginny

    ReplyDelete
  3. Kathryn's blog discusses Harry Potter and the related books as her popular culture focal point. As an avid fan of the Harry Potter series, any blog discussing anything related to Harry Potter interests me and attracts my attention. Her main idea is that even though this world we live in favors male authors over female, J.K. Rowling has still become a successful author and has become famous through her storytelling. This post has 3 paragraphs. In each, Kathryn builds up decent support for her ideas. However, i believe that more examples of successful female authors, as well as more specific evidence would improve the blog overall.

    The overall organization of the blog could use some work in my opinion. First off, somehow or another, your formatting got messed up and a whole third of your first paragraph is stranded out inside the second paragraph. You can tell by the differing fonts they each have. I also agree with Chu when she says that your paragraphs could relate more strongly and more cohesively to your main idea.

    Your language is good, and i like the formal, but not overly complicated wording. You might want to do a little proofreading to make sure all of your sentences are structurally sound and there aren't any fragments. I would also like to see some examples, possibly from the movies, of a female character carrying out those roles you defined in your third paragraph (like Madam Pomfrey doing her thing or Hermoine saving the day).

    ReplyDelete
  4. I will definitely reorganize - I had to change the main point a bit but didn't get a chance to rearrange yet. If I post another draft tonight, would you mind looking at it again? (just anytime before class tomorrow is fine) Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I'll definitely look at it again for ya

    ReplyDelete